Maxie, Rosie, and Earl: Partners in Grime

March 31, 1990
Maxie Zuckerman, age 10, is resented by his classmates for receiving top grades, and Maxie resents their resentment. Earl Wilber, new in town, is a lonely, nervous fourth-grader. In another classroom is a habitual tattler, Rosie Swanson. The three meet outside the principal's office (Maxie's guilty of cutting a hole in a bully's T-shirt, Earl is there for refusing to read aloud and Rosie's tattling is rattling her teacher) and embark on an escapade, thus forging a friendship that injects each with a dose of self-confidence. It's evident why these youngsters dislike school (their unreasonable teachers aren't much help), but they get away with some deceptive behavior. A promising premise is almost totally sidetracked here by a threadbare plot, trite dialogue--the author feels that a brief glossary is needed to explain the obscure vocabulary that comprises Maxie's insults--and less-than-appealing characters. While a subtle theme exists about the joys of friendship, any other pluses in this book are difficult to find. Ages 8 - 12.

July 10, 2006
This larky tale concerns three grade-schoolers--united by their abhorrence of matters academic--who meet outside the principal's office and forge a friendship that injects each with a dose of self-confidence. Ages 8-12.